If Alice is four Hatters over three tall, and eating a cookie makes her a Queen of Hearts taller, and drinking a bottle makes her a Cheshire cat smaller, how tall is she after consuming three cookies and two drinks?
Perhaps my word problem is a little less real-world, but I would argue it's about as real-world-like as the Babylon word problems, but a little more fun. I would think the idea being making the word problems realistic would be to make them easier to understand for the reader. There is some intuition to thinking about a problem that can be imagined, even if the grain pile is bigger than anything ever experienced, and even if it's just Alice growing taller and smaller. These problems create imagery in the mind of the reader, making something abstract like math more concrete to work with.
If we're just trying to make problems something more concrete for the imagination, why the weird numbers? I believe it was mentioned how for Babylonian word problems in particular, we want clean numbers that are easy for the solver to calculate. So we get back to having problems where the ideas can be conceptualized, but the numbers don't make any sense. I'm not entirely sure if there is a better way to go about these world problems, and perhaps that's why they've stayed the same for thousands of years. In modern math we're used to using math abstractly, which is where the question of whether word problems are more of a reading comprehension problem than a math one. As far as I remember the Babylonians didn't really express abstract math in the way we do today, and so testing comprehension of these problems would have been useful for testing their understanding of applying mathematical methods.
For my own class though, I think I'll leave them as something fun as there are better ways of testing math skills, and I'm clearly testing reading comprehension with word problems.
As for the clear answer, 15 feet tall, with the Hatter being 3 feet tall, the Queen 5 feet, and the Cheshire cat two.
I enjoyed your Alice in Wonderland problem! Your point about how word problems can make abstract mathematics easier to imagine, even when the situations are unrealistic, connects well with the reading. I also found your question about whether word problems assess mathematical understanding or reading comprehension interesting. It makes me think about what we actually want students to learn when we use word problems in our classrooms.
ReplyDeleteHear hear!!
ReplyDelete