Friday, October 23, 2026

Mathematics in Ancient Egypt - (For Oct 19th)

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj_Z7cxqMfw4JbQnnpDBCdpc3XfJ4Vlj0vWnGuugrwHOQLdZO-YFWtJsw64IeEVc43L6asw8cYUsStIPhwK49GZ8ylFFBFBIIGKZtaI9Vns__fkzOP7Z90gHSGIQYstLC7cl6qQB-TTwA/s1600/Rope+stretchers.jpg 

The first thing I notice is the knotted rope, which would be used for measuring distances. Most people seem to be holding a stick, and I can't quite make out what it is. My first assumption is a cubit stick? Like a stick that's a standard measurement, made out of wood. Although in the bottom panel it seems people are writing on the stick thing, so perhaps it's actually a tablet. Also in both the top panel and the bottom one there is a person with a bag of perhaps grain standing before someone with a strange stick. I'm not sure if this stick could someone weight things, or??? I suppose I'll have to read the article to find out.

Measurement in today's age feels like something quick, but looking at their methods of measurement I'm left with the question of how long it took them to measure everything? Although I guess walking with a rope isn't much slower than a trundle wheel. The picture has people scooping grains with buckets, are those buckets a measuring device and the surveyors are just counting and writing down how many are used? I guess there is the question of how much accuracy do you really need for the majority of daily tasks? I would think it wouldn't be too high, but if my farmland got shrunken quite a bit from the Nile river, I would like them to be as accurate as possible for the tax benefits. I was actually surprised at how important surveying was for taxation in ancient Egypt. Mostly because I didn't know they had taxes or cared so much about the land of their workers. They seem somewhat fair. I suppose you have a good structure to your society for it to last for 3000 years, I don't think capitalist America will last for 3000 years. With the way they treat the people, they're about ready for the French Revolution.

Reflection on A1 - Pyramid Frustum

Instruction wise, I feel as though I could have done much to improved the teaching experience. I provided examples on the board for the two most common modern methods to solve for a pyramid frustum, but I think I went through the examples too quickly. I talked to my fellow classmates after my presentation and one mentioned how they were not able to follow the math. I think to improve the teaching experience I need to slow down on my explanations, and really take the time to break them down. These lessons aren't very long and so I tend to go over thing quickly, which is much to the detriment of the lesson. The activity with the students went over fairly well, but perhaps I could have adjusted it to make it even more engaging for students to see how we can take the frustum of other shapes and break them down into fundamental shapes. I particularly like how using simple trig ratios the problem of the hexagonal pyramid frustum could be solved. The image above is the template I drew of the basic shapes to show the class. I had a lot of fun using my drafting experience/knowledge from engineering to draw it. The fact that these problems can be broken down into fundamentally simpler problems makes me wonder what other modern math problems I can break down for my class to make them easier to understand, or perhaps what other methods they could come up with given some scaffolding. Either way it's given me some ideas to bring into my teaching.

 

Saturday, October 3, 2026

Puzzlingly Simple - (Market Scale Puzzles - For Sept 28th)

 

I was honestly lost on this one for most of it, but then I eventually came back to trying out Egyptian multiplication. Looking at that method and how I might relate it back to this problem. That's when I eventually tried to build up numbers off of 1. I can go 1 then 2, but 2-1=1, so we already have a duplicate, thus go for 3. Using this I slowly built up, and the numbers did indeed equal to 40. Once you know the method it's easy to do the one pan scale. 1, then 2, which means we can get to 1+2=3, so then next is 4, and 1+2+4=7, so next is 8, 1+2+4+8=15, so next is 16, and 1,2,4,8,16 do in fact add up to 31. 
 
For extending the problem I could only think of them going up to higher numbers. I would start with them building two for four, three for 13, etc, to scaffold their learning. I could also ask how you could do that same thing but only with even numbers (multiply the weights by 2, as they give a sequence), could go even into positive and negative, or perhaps using variables to go into algebra. I think the math on learning about sequences is the strongest relation to understanding mathematics more deeply. 
 
If we're talking about number bases as in base 2, or base 10, or 60, the answer is irrelevant of the base. We use the same techniques. I thought the math kind of goes into set theory. The numbers are non-overlapping to give the biggest continuous sequence. The other way I could think about bases, is that 1,3,9,14,27 are the basis of the sequence from 1-40. 
 
Overall I love puzzles and I think ones like these are a fun way to teach math and introduce some theories or concepts.  

Worldly Wordy Word Problems - (Babylon Word Problems - For Sept 28th)


If Alice is four Hatters over three tall, and eating a cookie makes her a Queen of Hearts taller, and drinking a bottle makes her a Cheshire cat smaller, how tall is she after consuming three cookies and two drinks?

Perhaps my word problem is a little less real-world, but I would argue it's about as real-world-like as the Babylon word problems, but a little more fun. I would think the idea being making the word problems realistic would be to make them easier to understand for the reader. There is some intuition to thinking about a problem that can be imagined, even if the grain pile is bigger than anything ever experienced, and even if it's just Alice growing taller and smaller. These problems create imagery in the mind of the reader, making something abstract like math more concrete to work with. 

If we're just trying to make problems something more concrete for the imagination, why the weird numbers? I believe it was mentioned how for Babylonian word problems in particular, we want clean numbers that are easy for the solver to calculate. So we get back to having problems where the ideas can be conceptualized, but the numbers don't make any sense. I'm not entirely sure if there is a better way to go about these world problems, and perhaps that's why they've stayed the same for thousands of years. In modern math we're used to using math abstractly, which is where the question of whether word problems are more of a reading comprehension problem than a math one. As far as I remember the Babylonians didn't really express abstract math in the way we do today, and so testing comprehension of these problems would have been useful for testing their understanding of applying mathematical methods.

For my own class though, I think I'll leave them as something fun as there are better ways of testing math skills, and I'm clearly testing reading comprehension with word problems.

As for the clear answer, 15 feet tall, with the Hatter being 3 feet tall, the Queen 5 feet, and the Cheshire cat two. 

Mathematics in Ancient Egypt - (For Oct 19th)

  The first thing I notice is the knotted rope, which would be used for measuring distances. Most people seem to be holding a stick, and I c...