Saturday, October 3, 2026

Puzzlingly Simple - (Market Scale Puzzles - For Sept 28th)

 

I was honestly lost on this one for most of it, but then I eventually came back to trying out Egyptian multiplication. Looking at that method and how I might relate it back to this problem. That's when I eventually tried to build up numbers off of 1. I can go 1 then 2, but 2-1=1, so we already have a duplicate, thus go for 3. Using this I slowly built up, and the numbers did indeed equal to 40. Once you know the method it's easy to do the one pan scale. 1, then 2, which means we can get to 1+2=3, so then next is 4, and 1+2+4=7, so next is 8, 1+2+4+8=15, so next is 16, and 1,2,4,8,16 do in fact add up to 31. 
 
For extending the problem I could only think of them going up to higher numbers. I would start with them building two for four, three for 13, etc, to scaffold their learning. I could also ask how you could do that same thing but only with even numbers (multiply the weights by 2, as they give a sequence), could go even into positive and negative, or perhaps using variables to go into algebra. I think the math on learning about sequences is the strongest relation to understanding mathematics more deeply. 
 
If we're talking about number bases as in base 2, or base 10, or 60, the answer is irrelevant of the base. We use the same techniques. I thought the math kind of goes into set theory. The numbers are non-overlapping to give the biggest continuous sequence. The other way I could think about bases, is that 1,3,9,14,27 are the basis of the sequence from 1-40. 
 
Overall I love puzzles and I think ones like these are a fun way to teach math and introduce some theories or concepts.  

2 comments:

  1. Your idea of starting with fewer weights and gradually increasing the challenge could help students recognize the pattern before tackling the full problem. I wonder at what point students might begin to predict the next weight without having to test all the combinations.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Leiah, I see your solution for both the 40 grams (on the two-pan scale) and the 31 grams (on the one-pan scale) in your handwritten sheet photographed here. That is great! But your typed write up doesn't really make sense... For example, you say that 3+2+1=8 (!!), and you seem to be mixing up the two-pan and one-pan scales in a confusing way.
    ** Revision needed: Could you please revise your write up so that it makes sense with your good handwritten account? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete

Mathematics in Ancient Egypt - (For Oct 19th)

  The first thing I notice is the knotted rope, which would be used for measuring distances. Most people seem to be holding a stick, and I c...